
Pre-call
Can You Trust AI Sales Call Scores? Four Questions to Ask Any Tool
An AI call score earns trust when each mark points to the buyer’s own words and the vendor says what the score does not prove.
Key takeaways
- 01Trust an AI call score as far as you can check it, which means a quote from the call behind each mark and a plain label where the evidence is missing.
- 02Published research finds language models can state things their source does not support and can answer differently on the same input, so a bare number is a weak basis for a decision.
- 03Ask any vendor four questions: is each score tied to a quote, can I read that quote, what happens with too little evidence, and is there a published independent benchmark.
- 04Quotadot drops a readiness dimension whose quote is not in the transcript and marks a gap unproven, and it has published no independent accuracy benchmark for the index.
You can trust an AI call score as far as you can check it. A score earns trust when every mark points to the buyer's own words, a gap is labelled as a gap, and the vendor says plainly what the score does not prove. A number with no evidence behind it asks you to take the model's word for it.
That is the standard we hold the Buyer Readiness Index to. Below are the reasons for doubt, four questions for any tool, and where our index stops.
Why are AI call scores hard to trust?
Four problems sit under most of the doubt. None of them belongs to one vendor.
The model can state what the call did not say. Summarizing a call is a form of what researchers call abstractive summarization. A study of those systems at ACL 2020 found them "highly prone to hallucinate content that is unfaithful to the input document" (Maynez et al., May 2, 2020, fetched November 16, 2026).
A citation is not proof. A source helps only if it says what the claim says. An audit of four generative search engines found that "only 74.5% of citations support their associated sentence" (Liu et al., April 19, 2023, fetched November 16, 2026). A score that shows a quote beats one that shows nothing. The quote can still be the wrong evidence for the mark.
The same input can get a different answer. Researchers ran five models set up to be deterministic on eight tasks, ten runs each. They report that "none of the LLMs consistently delivers repeatable accuracy across all tasks, much less identical output strings" (Atil et al., revised April 2, 2025, fetched November 16, 2026).
Readiness has no answer key. A deal's outcome gets recorded. The buyer's readiness on a given call does not, so a readiness score is an inference. Deal scores lean on closed deals instead. To see Gong's deal likelihood scores, a company must have "At least 50 deals that were closed-won in the last 2 years" and "At least 150 deals that were closed-lost in the last 2 years" (Gong help center, February 25, 2026, fetched November 16, 2026).
How do vendors explain their scores?
The better vendors document what their number means. The table compares how three scores are explained.
| Score | What the number is | What explains it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quotadot Buyer Readiness Index | A readiness score from 0 to 100 for one buyer after each call, with five dimensions | Each dimension marked strong or weak carries a verbatim quote from the transcript | Buyer Readiness Index page |
| Gong deal likelihood score | "a percentile rank that indicates the relative deal health" | "the positive and negative signals that were weighed in to calculate its value" | Gong help center |
| Salesforce Einstein Opportunity Scoring | Opportunity scores shown in High, Med and Low tiers in Pipeline Inspection | "the factors that positively and negatively influence this score" | Salesforce Trailhead |
Source: the Quotadot row comes from the product page linked in it, and the other rows quote each vendor's own documentation, such as Gong's explainer, updated October 13, 2026, fetched November 16, 2026.
Method and limits: the table compares how each score is explained, not which one is more accurate. Gong and Salesforce score deals, and Quotadot scores one buyer's evidence on one call, so the scores answer different questions.
Gong also says what its number is not. Its explainer states the score "neither signifies that the deal has an 80% chance of closing nor is it the deal's expected win rate". That sentence is worth looking for in any vendor's documentation.
What should you ask any vendor?
Four questions separate a score you can check from one you have to believe.
- Is each score tied to a quote? Ask which words from the call support each part of the score. A list of factors explains a model. A quote explains a call.
- Can I read the quote and check it? The quote should sit next to the mark, word for word. Then read it and decide whether it supports the mark, because a real quote can still be the wrong evidence.
- What happens with too little evidence? A trustworthy tool says it does not know. Be wary of a full set of confident marks after a short call.
- Is there a published independent benchmark? Ask for an accuracy study run by someone other than the vendor, on calls like yours. If there is none, ask the vendor to say so in writing and test the score on your own deals.
How does the Buyer Readiness Index answer the four questions?
After each call, Quotadot evaluates five dimensions of buyer readiness: Pain Recognition, Trust Formation, Problem Urgency, Solution Confidence and Commitment Behavior. Each is marked strong, weak or unproven.
A quote behind each mark. Every dimension marked strong or weak carries a verbatim quote from the transcript. A compliment like "this looks great" counts for nothing. An action a skeptic would accept counts.
A quote you can check. Before a dimension is shown, its quote is checked against the transcript. A dimension whose quote is not in the transcript is dropped, and each dimension uses a buyer line that no other dimension has used whenever one is available. Reps and managers read the quote under each dimension and judge the reasoning themselves.
A gap stays a gap. A dimension gets no mark it cannot quote. A short call, or one without real signal, leaves the dimensions it cannot back with the buyer's words unscored or marked unproven. An unproven dimension tells the rep what to ask on the next call.
No published benchmark. Quotadot has not published an independent accuracy benchmark for its Buyer Readiness Index. Test it on your own won and lost deals, as the Buyer Readiness Index guide describes.
When a CRM is connected, Stage–Readiness Alignment compares that evidence with the deal's CRM stage. Buyer readiness versus deal stage walks through why the two disagree.
What does the index not prove?
The quote check proves the words are in the transcript. It does not prove the transcript heard them right. Speech-to-text runs on the rep's computer, in English only, and like any transcription it can mishear words, names or terms. If the transcript is materially wrong, a corrected transcript can be added to the buyer's record and analyzed again. AI sales call transcription errors covers that side.
The quote check also does not prove the mark is right. Whether a quote shows strong or weak commitment is still an AI judgment. That is why the quote is on screen.
The score is evidence-backed decision support. It is not a prediction that a deal will close. Quotadot does not claim the score is repeatable from run to run, calibrated against outcomes, or validated by an outside party. The final judgment remains with the salesperson and sales manager.
How Quotadot works shows where the index sits in the loop, and the security page covers what happens to the transcript.
Frequently asked questions
Can I trust the buyer readiness scores generated by Quotadot's AI?
Quotadot's Buyer Readiness Index is designed to make AI sales analysis explainable and verifiable, rather than relying on an unexplained score. Read the full answer.
Why can an AI score the same call differently?
Language models do not always give the same answer to the same input. A study of five models set up to be deterministic found that none delivered repeatable accuracy across all eight tasks tested. A score that shows its evidence lets you check each run instead of trusting the number.
Does a quote under a score prove the score is right?
No. A quote that is in the transcript proves the buyer said those words, as far as the transcript heard them. Whether the words support the mark is a judgment you should check by reading the quote.
Does the Buyer Readiness Index predict whether a deal will close?
No. It is decision support built on the buyer's evidence from each call, and Quotadot publishes no independent accuracy benchmark for it.


